Date: Tue, 31 Jul 2001 16:04:37 -0400 (EDT)
From: Leslie E. Phillips <Leslie.E.Phillips@Dartmouth.EDU>
To: Multiple recipients of list CX-L <cx-l@debate.net>
Subject: Re: NEG Args for CX-L (forwarded from Sheryl A. Kaczmarek)
DARTMOUTH DEBATE INSTITUTE
July 15 - August 12, 2001
Negative Arguments
Cheshier/Garen
Allied Prolif Germany, Taiwan, South Korea, Japan
Bargaining Chip CP use the plan to lever specific bilateral concessions (working especially on Russia and China scenarios,
for example to use the offer of plan as a bargaining chip to force/induce human rights improvements or economic reform)
Bush Impacts TSEA, trade, fast track, lots of NMD work
India/Pakistan Consult India, Indian encirclement, looking for a good Indo-Pak scenario
International Law Good/Bad and UN Good/Bad includes a DA that unilateral arms control (or bilateral) co-opts/subverts the
broader development of global disarmament architectures
Israeli Reaction DA and Israel Consultation CP, plus some Iranian politics arguments specific to the Iraqi sanctions
K of "WMD" (shouldn't expand the term) and policy arguments that WMD limits will induce shifts to next generation
weapons
Malthus standard old-fashioned version...
Spending Federal budget breakdown
May potentially write (but nothing yet and no one assigned): K of "disaster porn," K "genocide trivi8alization," K
"statism/defense of anarchy," shunning
Reworking the major kritiks, Russia, Japan and Europe
Likely to develop major policy positions specific to the North Korea and Iraq affirmatives, but we're just starting that...
Cunningham/Hoe
Allied Prolif DA
Bush Trade promotion and NMD scenarios
Compassion Fatigue K
Deterrence DA
European Defense Force vs. NATO DA both ways
Grand Negotiator Disad
Virtual Arsenals CP (Conventional WALS and Asteroid Net Benefit)
Davis/Saloom
Consult UN
Cultural Imperialism
Genocide/Holocaust Triv
India/Pak DA CTB Neg; H/L Good =Link
Israel DA (Relations and Peace Process Good)
Malthus
Militariam (It's Bad)
Oil DA (Caspian)
Orientalism
Spark
Garen/Russell
Case Negs for all Cases
Israel DA reduced U.S. hard-line on nuclear weapons or on Iran/Iraq curses Israeli disclosure; and relations impacts
Non-Violence Bad
Rework International Relations Critique with Threat Construction Anticipated new arguments include International Law
Critique (masks U.S. domination) and a new Bandrillard argument, most likely disaster porn, but may include other
hyper-reality evidence
Rework Politics/Bush DA new link work on swap arms control for NMD, fast track scenarios
Rework Russia Nationalism; unilateralism links; a new CP to condition the plan on Russian arms sales to Iran
Rework Spanos
Topicality
Horowitz/McIntosh
Critical IR Now combines Campbell with Spanos
Israel DA Plan is nice to "X" country, this kills U.S.-Israel Relations
Revised Aff: Ban Counter-force targeting. Same advantages as de-alerting.
Sparacino/Strange
Asteroid Protection
Casework and reworking of a few generics
CBW Shift (New Next Week)
China Sphere (New Next Week)
"Grand Negotiator"
Japan Soft Power (New Next Week)
NMD Both Ways
Powell Credibility
Putin Credibility (New Next Week)
Spending DA
=============== CX-L Mailing List ==============To unsubscribe: send the text UNSUBSCRIBE CX-L to listproc@debate.net with
NO SUBJECT. For other help, send mail to jordyn@debate.net. Fear the Kvaal!
|
