Date: Mon, 21 Sep 1998 11:33:19 -0400 (EDT)
From: Mark Webber <mhsdebate@hotmail.com>
To: Multiple recipients of list CX-L <cx-l@debate.net>
Subject: case list from Greenhill
*****PLEASE READ THIS PART FIRST!!!!!!!!!!!!
I am sending this to the list serve in hopes that it will encourage
others to share information that they may have. I find it amazing that a
bunch of hypocrites get on the list serve and post HUNDREDS!!!!! of
messages about how your all about education and OPEN DISCLOSURE and not
one single tight -ass has posted ANY OF THE CASES FROM WAKE. Either put
up or shut up!
on the other hand, I would like to thank debaters , coaches and
observers who attended the Greenhill Tournament and took time to stop
after rounds and give me full descriptions of the cases that they saw or
were actually running themselves or plan to run in the future. If others
have info or corrections to this list, please post it.
be cool,
webber
case list from greenhill
Albequerque
plan:
do BMD
Barbers Hill
plan:
assure Russia that we will freeze NATO expansion
adv: nationalism
adv: accidental launch/hair trigger
(2nd case)
plan: establish a currency board tying the ruble to the dollar
Bettendorf KL
plan:
consult russia and stop NATO expansion
adv: alienate russia=military threat=nukes
GBS BF
plan:ban troops/nukes
Caddo LS (A and B teams run this)
plan:
assure Russia on Nato expansion
adv: neo-imperialism(supposedly the same as cultural imperialism)
adv: START II/accidental launch
adv::fragmentation of CIS through exp.
Cathedral Prep
plan: mandate f/g give all early warning systems to Russia
adv: accidental war Y2K
Centerville (A team)
cooperate on pathogen research
adv: :bioweapons/research snowballs
adv::disease
College Prep
inh: pushing mox/ gtmrs will be cut/ complete them
plan:complete GTMHR program and open negotiations w/ Russia
adv: prolif/
MOX leakage accidents
Colleyville RY
plan:
overturn 1993 agreement re :can launch 10 satellites in russia right
now (russia is most comp. sat. mkt ) /open to free markets
adv: :competitiveness/ our satellite market is weak and competition with
Russia will boost our market.
adv: hegemony
(stops protectionism)
(also runs Low till Tractors and sutainable agriculture education)
Colleyville B
consult w/ russia on building BMD
adv: relations
adv: brain drain
(mitchell "97- aff author)
Damien (all teams)
plan:
Ban BMD
adv: wasted fortunes
adv: china
Edgemont BS
plan:
ban BMD
Edgemont Team A and B
Ban BMD
adv: preemptive strike
adv: accidents
El Cerrito
plan :Yeltsin Focus (shift diplomacy away exclusive Yeltsin ???)
adv::Nationalism
adv::support grass roots movements =Democracy
GBS BG
plan:
renew and compromise tactical weapons treaty (Bush/Gorbachev
treaty-1991) compromise by pulling tactical weapons out of NATO
countries.
Adv. 1 nuclear conflict (nukes on russian border)
Adv. 2 Theft (Blair 97) tactical nukes not safe(russia's)
adv::accidental launch
GBN PS
plan:
tobacco
GBN MM
plan:
ban BMD
Georgetown A team
talk-talk(low level diplomacy)
Georgetown B team
plan: decommision old submarines
Grapevine
Plan:
abandon Start II and do Start III
Strategic Integrated Operational Protocols
do suggestions of Mazzar and Moore - scale back to virtual nuclear
arsenal
adv: accidental war
(no stance on start II)
Greenhill A Team
-PEP (economy) Production Assistance
adv:: democracy promotion
-Tobacco (Dartmouth version)
-FBI in replacement of the CIA gets jurisdiction over tracking loose
nukes in Russia(institute case/ not the same version as wake case)
Hays BW
AIDS - condoms
Head Royce FV
ban 2nd round NATO
expansion
adv::accidental launch
adv: : relations
adv::nationalism
Heritage Hall
plan: Taberculosis/ Dots
Hopkins CK
plan:
currency boards
adv:
scen 1: russian economic collapse = nuclear anarchy
scen: 2 global economic collapse
Iowa City West LP
plan: phase out first strike
Iowa City West
Reciprocal Unilateral Arms Reductions
adv:: nukes bad
Isidore-Newman
plan: ban tobacco experts
adv: 1/2 million lung cancer deaths yearly
Lee (San Antonio)
Norad
possibly Tobacco in the future
Lexington BB
plan: take control from private sector subcontractor to gather uranium
and regovernmentalize.
adv: prolif
adv: nuclear leakage
enriched uranium
plan: highly enriched uranium act
gives authority to DOE=buys russian uranium.
adv: prolif
adv: terrorism
Highland Park MP
plan: regovernmentalize highly enriched uranium (similar to Lexington
case above but does not mention DOE)
harms=privates buy the cheap uranium and don't really buy the russian
uranium. russia will sell it, but to who......)
adv::prolif
Lexington CL
plan:
stop tracking subs/sub bumping
adv: sub collisions (environment)
adv: accidental launch/ escalation
MBA IS
plan:
ban BMD
remove NMD research
adv:: accidents
adv:: nationalism
adv: nmd deployment=china vertically proliferates
adv: defense races
underview: nmd will ultimately fail
Memorial IK
plan : talk/talk (low level diplomacy)
Millard West(A Team)
renegotiate with Russia on joint BMD
adv::prolif
adv:accidents
Newburg Free Academy
plan: consult Russia on banning NATO expansion (plan text may be
changing re: consultation)
Omaha Westside
plan: CSIS strengthen crime fighting to solve Mafia
adv: economy
Ottumwa(Iowa)
plan: pass pathogens initiative (national academy o sciences evidence)
adv: bio-weapons prolif w/ terrorism
Pace
plan:cooperate with Russia on BMD
adv:: proliferation
adv::accidental launch
adv::relations
Valley cs
plan:
ban ASATs
Plano East
plan: ban NATO expansion
adv::nationalism
adv: relations
South Garland
plan: Y2K
adv: accidental launch
adv: economy
______________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com
============================== CX-L Mailing List =============================
To unsubscribe: send the text UNSUBSCRIBE CX-L to listproc@debate.net with
NO SUBJECT. For other help, send mail to jordyn@debate.net. Fear the Kvaal!
Date: Tue, 22 Sep 1998 11:15:35 -0400 (EDT)
From: Mark Webber <mhsdebate@hotmail.com>
To: Multiple recipients of list CX-L <cx-l@debate.net>
Subject: additions to the greenhill case list
Dr.Debate@aol.com wrote:
If you want to add it to you case list...
Los Alamitos BH
Steven Benken
Gaven Henderson
Plan: Ban importation of raw Russian logs to the US and prevent
investment in
Russian logging.
Advantages: Russian Deforestation, US Deforestation
El Cerrito shifts focus away from Yeltins political actions. The
advantages are
nationalism and democracy promotion. Its similar to public diplomacy,
but the
actors are still the govt just on a lower level like local and regional
leaders.
USA Today was the main solvency author.
New Trier A runs Tobacco- ban trade policy 301, and eliminate propaganda
with
tobacco bad as the adv.
New Trier B runs vitrifications with prolif and
accidents
as adv. the text is really odd bc they ban dual track use of mox and
vitrification
to pure vitrification-
Peace out,
Ben
Georgetown High School
thanx to dr.debate and ben for sending these in.
yall be cool,
webber
still amazed that people aren't posting wake info to the list!!!!!
______________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com
============================== CX-L Mailing List =============================
To unsubscribe: send the text UNSUBSCRIBE CX-L to listproc@debate.net with
NO SUBJECT. For other help, send mail to jordyn@debate.net. Fear the Kvaal!
|
