Date: Fri, 2 Apr 1999 00:04:44 -0500 (EST)
From: tim alderete <timalderete@yahoo.com>
To: Multiple recipients of list CX-L <cx-l@debate.net>
Subject: Iowa City West Novice Nationals - Results
Haven't been on for a couple of weeks. Haven't seen results posted for
this yet.
Speaker Awards:
1. Clint South - Mars Hill
2. Keith Bernstein - Maine East
3. Nikki Braziel - Evanston
4. Will Tucker - Iowa City City
5. Ryan Travis - Holland
6. Zach Fridell - New Boston
7. Sonny Patel - Maine East
8. Brad Hall - New Boston
9. Dan Deacon - Evanston
10. Sandra Maroska - Evanston
Octofinals:
1. Mars Hill (AL) South/Webb def
16. Centerville (OH) Buckles/Elsas
2. Evanston (IL) Braziel/Deacon def
15. Dowling (IA) Lantz/Nelson
14. Holland (MI) Goolsby / Murillio def
3. Maine East (IL) Loseya/Moore
13. EGR/East Lansing (MI) Bye/Warmels def
4. Evanston (IL) Maroska/Pituch
5. Evanston (IL) Hamilton/Seeskin def
12. Valley (IA) Kelly / Kumar
6. Houston Memorial (TX) Simpson/Sucato over
11. Houston Memorial (TX) Gupta/Sim
7. Woodward (GA) Marietta/Shah def
10. Holland (MI) Saal/Travis
8. Maine East (IL) Grotberg/Zacharia over
9. Maine East (IL) Bernstein/Patel
Quarters:
1. Mars Hill SW def 8. Maine East GZ
7. Woodward MS def 2. Evanston BD
6. Memorial SS def 14. Holland GM
5. Evanston HS def 13. EGR/EL BW
Semis:
1. Mars Hill SW def 5. Evanston HS
6. Memorial SS def 7. Woodward MS
In the final round, Mars Hill defeated Houston Memorial on a 3-2.
Memorial was Aff and ran Fund ISS and Mir with Co-op advantages.
Alderete, Antonucci, and Karen Scott Voted Neg for Mars Hill on Spanos.
Langgin and Takis Makridis voted Aff on a Performative Contradiction.
A couple of comments:
First - Having judged novice debate as well as a few varsity debates
over the last 14 years, I can honestly say that the final round was one
of the best Novice debates I have seen. All of the judges were extremely
impressed, and both teams and their coaches are to be congratulated.
Second - A Massive Plug for this Tournament. Add it to your tournament
schedule next year. It has extremely good novice competition, it is well
run, it is well-timed and inexpensive enough to fit most programs, and
it gives Novices a tournament where they can get the attention and
respect that we cannot always give them at other tournaments. Lavish
gifts are given for everything from Best Ballot competitions to
surviving to judge the finals. Thanks to Greg Myrberg and everyone else
who ran a great show. You should go.
Third - Congrats to Northwestern for winning the NDT, from an old Alum.
Fourth- I must say that I feel a little bad about voting for Spanos,
since he is a Holocaust Revisionist.
Tim Alderete
EGR Debate
HAVE A NICE DAY!!! - Mick Foley (god)
_________________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com
============================== CX-L Mailing List =============================
To unsubscribe: send the text UNSUBSCRIBE CX-L to listproc@debate.net with
NO SUBJECT. For other help, send mail to jordyn@debate.net. Fear the Kvaal!
|
