Admin Args Case Lists Invites Judges Miscellany Results Theory TOC Topics
Back to the main page


hsdebate.com: Policy_Isidore_Newman.html

Date:           Tue, 15 Dec 1998 20:18:36 EST
From:           JS5581@aol.com
To:             BGStults@aol.com
Subject:        (no subject)

Today we wrapped up the 21th Newman Invitational.  we had teams from 11 
states and 60 schools.  But I know that none of you care about that.  
So, to the results.(Only CX b/c we don't care about LD either)
Octos
Grapevine GU def.  North Meck ???
Colleyville Heritage RL closeout Colleyville Heritage ES
Taylor KW def. Hays ???
Greenhill OH def. Taylor ST
Niceviille GT def. MOuntain Brook ???
Lee FS def.  Caddo GM
Grapevine LM def. Ruston GK
Caddo HS def. Jesuit SL

Quaters
Grapevine GU def. Caddo HS
Colleyville Heritage RL def. Lee FS
Greenhill OH def. Grapevine LM
Niceville GT def. Taylor KW

Semis
Greenhill OH def. Colleyville Heritage RL
Grapevine GU def. NIceville GT

Finals
(One of the strangest rounds I have ever watched.)
Greenhill OH vs. Grapevine GU
decision
Stults--- double win
Bain--  double loss
Sykes-- no decision

The aff. presented a realism aff and Grapevine decided to read poetry  
to answer the aff.  In the cx of the 2ac they talked about giving double 
wins.  The debate could not be decided either way and the judges thought 
that the best way to preserve discourse without providing competitive 
edges, i.e. laziness and the use of the stategies in the orund to obtain 
double wins, was the decision rendered.  Both teams recieved a fist and 
second place award.
Josh Skora
Isidore Newman